Blueprints Certified Studies
Risk and Protective Factors
Subgroup Analysis Details
Race/Ethnicity Specific Findings
- White
- Hispanic or Latino
- African American
- Other
Subgroup Analysis Details
Seventy-seven percent of participants were white; most of the remaining adolescents were either Black (11%) or Hispanic (7%).
Training and Technical Assistance
Benefits and Costs
Source: Washington State Institute for Public Policy
All benefit-cost ratios are the most recent estimates published by The Washington State Institute for Public Policy for Blueprint programs implemented in Washington State. These ratios are based on a) meta-analysis estimates of effect size and b) monetized benefits and calculated costs for programs as delivered in the State of Washington. Caution is recommended in applying these estimates of the benefit-cost ratio to any other state or local area. They are provided as an illustration of the benefit-cost ratio found in one specific state. When feasible, local costs and monetized benefits should be used to calculate expected local benefit-cost ratios. The formula for this calculation can be found on the WSIPP website.
Program Costs
No information is available
Funding Strategies
No information is available
Evaluation Abstract
Program Developer/Owner
Program Specifics
Program Type
- Academic Services
- Community - Other Approaches
- Drug Prevention/Treatment
- Juvenile Justice - Other
Program Setting
- Transitional Between Contexts
Continuum of Intervention
- Indicated Prevention
- Selective Prevention
Program Goals
A transitional program designed to help at-risk or adjudicated youth, through restorative principles, to positively change their attitudes in order to be happier, more productive individuals.
Population Demographics
Youth were referred to the CSF Buxmont program from three sources: juvenile probation (56% or n = 516), children and youth services (10% or n = 88), and individual school districts (34% or n = 315).
Target Population
Age
- Late Adolescence (15-18) - High School
- Early Adolescence (12-14) - Middle School
Gender
Race/Ethnicity
Race/Ethnicity Specific Findings
- White
- Hispanic or Latino
- African American
- Other
Subgroup Analysis Details
Seventy-seven percent of participants were white; most of the remaining adolescents were either Black (11%) or Hispanic (7%).
Other Risk and Protective Factors
Risk: Substance use, early and persistent antisocial behavior, family history of problem behavior, lack of commitment to school, favorable attitudes toward the problem behavior, friends who engage in the problem behavior.
Risk/Protective Factors
Risk Factors
Protective Factors
*Risk/Protective Factor was significantly impacted by the program
Brief Description of the Program
CSF Buxmont Schools are a collection of six school/day treatment programs. These programs are non-secure community treatment settings for adjudicated delinquent and at-risk youth. There are three additional auxiliary programs--the residential, intensive supervision, and home and community programs. Students attending CSF schools often attend several of these programs simultaneously. The residential program provides students with group home services. The intensive supervision program provides additional support to youth released from drug treatment facilities. Finally, the home and community program provides support services for youth experiencing family, emotional, and drug and alcohol related crises.
Description of the Program
CSF Buxmont Schools are a collection of six school/day treatment programs. These programs are non-secure community treatment settings for adjudicated delinquent and at-risk youth. There are three additional auxiliary programs--the residential, intensive supervision, and home and community programs. Students attending CSF schools often attend several of these programs simultaneously. The residential program provides students with home group services. The intensive supervision program provides additional support to youth released from drug treatment facilities. Finally, the home and community program provides support services for youth experiencing family, emotional, and drug and alcohol related crises.
All of these programs utilize restorative principles in staff-youth interactions, as well as in staff-staff and youth-youth relationships. Within this framework, youth are held accountable for their actions while being given the social and emotional support necessary to make changes. Restorative principles empower youth to develop their own behavioral standards and actively confront misbehavior.
Youths attend CSF Buxmont schools for a variable amount of time. The primary factor determining the length of exposure was discharge type. There are two primary discharge types: 1) Normal Discharge -- Youth successfully completes the program by returning to public school, graduating or receiving GED, or upon turning 18 years old. 2) Behavioral Discharge -- Youth is discharged prior to completing program for failure to attend, running away, showing repeated noncompliance with program directives, violating conditions of their probation, or for an arrest resulting in a new placement. The average length of exposure was 104 school days (20.9 weeks), with a minimum of none (2 youths) and a maximum of 531 days (106 weeks). Some CSF Buxmont students participate in multiple programs simultaneously.
Theoretical Rationale
CSF Buxmont Academy employs restorative practices to individuals in their school and auxiliary programs. These practices provide high levels of control and support to encourage appropriate behavior. The philosophy underlying these principles is that human beings are happier, more productive, and more likely to make positive changes in their behavior when those in positions of authority do things "with" them, rather than "to" them or "for" them. This hypothesis maintains that the punitive and authoritarian "to" mode and the permissive and paternalistic "for" mode are not as effective as the restorative, participatory, and engaging "with" mode.
Theoretical Orientation
Brief Evaluation Methodology
This study evaluated the effectiveness of the restorative principles in encouraging positive behavioral change. Researchers evaluated all youth released from CSF Buxmont schools between June 1, 1999 and August 30, 2001. The total number of youth released in that time span was 919, including 140 from the final two weeks of the 1998-1999 school years, 334 from the 1999-2000 year, and 445 from the 2000-2001 year. The CSF Buxmont schools were evaluated using a protocol titled the Program Development and Evaluation System (ProDES). Researchers collected information on each youth's current offense, prior record, socio-demographic information, and family structure. ProDES also utilized information related to risk and needs assessments, and self-esteem and values assessments, all of which it evaluated at three points: program entry, program discharge, and a six-month follow-up. Additional information was obtained in two further studies that evaluated a second Wave of 858 youth discharged from CSF Buxmont day treatment programs during September-August school years of 2001-2002 and 2002 and 2003 (McCold 2005), and decreases in offending among 3,928 youth (Wave 3) discharged from CSF Buxmont schools between 2004 and 2006, respectively (McCold and Chang, 2008).
Outcomes (Brief, over all studies)
Individuals who were discharged for normal reasons averaged 118 days in the CSF program, compared to 77.2 school days for behaviorally discharged adolescents. Youth referred by probation or charged with drug offenses were more likely to complete the program than other groups, while black females were significantly less likely to complete the program than any other demographic. For youth who were normally discharged, there was an average increase in attitudinal measures of 10.6%, while no similar significant increase was witnessed for behavioral discharges. Youth with normal discharges were more likely to experience increases in self-esteem than individuals discharged for behavioral reasons (27% vs. 14%). Finally, individuals discharged for behavioral reasons were almost twice as likely as those with normal discharges to reoffend (15.1% vs. 7.9%).
Wave 1 (McCold 2005): The recidivism rate was reduced from 24% to 15% for behavior discharges for those completing three months of day treatment. In addition, youths discharged normally reduced their reoffending from 19% to 9.5%, a 50% reduction for those participating more than 3 months.
The effect from three months of participation was still evident by 24 months from discharge, although substantially reduced. Participation of 3 months or more for behavior-discharged youths was associated with a 20% reduction in new court petitions and by 13% for those discharged normally. The trends in reoffending maintained their ranking at the 6-month period throughout the 24-months, with youths discharged for their behavior with less than three months participation having the highest rate (48%) and those discharged normally with more than three months the lowest (32%). Youths who received CSF community services following discharge from day treatment (n = 180) received an average of five months care, after which their recidivism rate accelerated through the end of the first year to nearly match that of the short-stay behaviorally-discharged youths.
Wave 2: The effect of participating in the CSF Buxmont day treatment program for more than three months displayed the same pattern of new court petitions at 6 months as did Wave 1. The rate of recidivism for youths discharged for their behavior declined after three months of participation by 8%, compared to a 44% reduction for youths normally discharged.
A number of multivariate analyses on the Wave 2 data revealed that the factors most closely related to the risk of receiving a new court petition within 6 months of release were gender and age on first petition. The younger the youth at the first court petition, the greater the rate of recidivism. Youths with no prior petitions have the lowest rate of recidivism. Moreover, the rate of recidivism Was higher for boys than for girls, regardless of the age at first petition.
These results were highly correlated with the number of prior arrests, number of petitions, age at first out-of-home placement and risk scales computed from intake data. These other variables became insignificantly related to recidivism once gender and age at first petition were entered. Since these data were available on all youths with court checks, these two measures were used to create an expected rate of recidivism. The linear slopes were computed separately for boys and girls, and the expected probability for receiving a new court petition was calculated from these equations. Youths with no prior court petition were assigned an expected rate of 0%. The reduction in new court petitions from three months participation changed little for behavior at 13% and was reduced to 30% for normal discharges when youths petitioned for probation violation were removed from the sample.
Multivariate analysis found that the number of days present in treatment was significantly associated with lower recidivism, even after controlling the effects related to prior record (number of petitions, number of prior arrests, age on admission), gender and reason for program discharge. Finally, although the overall level of recidivism was a bit higher in the Wave 2 sample, the expected nonlinear effect of program participation was evident.
Wave 3 (McCold and Chang 2008): This evaluation demonstrated results of a significant recidivism supression effect from participation in the program among students who were discharged during the three school years ending in August 2004, 2005 and 2006 (Wave 3). The reduction was in direct relationship to the length of program participation and it persisted independent of the effects of pre-existing risk factors such as age of first offending, number of prior petitions, gender, and race.
Outcomes
- Youth referred by probation or charged with drug offenses were more likely to complete the program than other groups, while black females were significantly less likely to complete the program than any other demographic.
- For youth normally discharged, there was an average increase in attitudinal measures of 10.6%, while no similar significant increase was witnessed for behavioral discharges.
- Youth with normal discharges were more likely to experience increases in self-esteem than individuals discharged for behavioral reasons (27% vs. 14%).
- Individuals discharged for behavioral reasons were almost twice as likely as those with normal discharges to reoffend (15.1% vs. 7.9%).
McCold 2005 - For Wave 1, the recidivism rate was reduced by 9% for behavior discharges among those completing three months of day treatment, while normally discharged youths reduced their reoffending by 50% among those participating more than 3 months.
- The effects from three months of participation were sustained at 24 months, although substantially reduced.
- Participation of 3 months or more for behavior-discharged youths was associated with a 20% reduction in new court petitions and by 13% for those discharged normally. These trends were sustained throughout the 24-months, with youths discharged for their behavior with less than three months participation having the highest rate (48%) and those discharged normally with more than three months the lowest (32%).
- Youths who received CSF community services following discharge from day treatment demonstrated an accelerated rate of recidivism through the end of the first year to nearly match that of the short-stay behaviorally-discharged youths.
- For Wave 2, the rate of recidivism for youths discharged for their behavior declined by 8% after three months of participation, compared to a 44% reduction for youths normally discharged.
- The rate of recidivism was higher for boys than for girls, regardless of the age at first petition in Wave 2.
- The number of days present in treatment was significantly associated with lower recidivism for Wave 2, even after controlling the effects related to prior record (number of petitions, number of prior arrests, age on admission), gender and reason for program discharge.
McCold and Chang 2008 - For Wave 3, there was a statistically significant positive program dosage effect on future offending behavior generally favoring youth who completed the program and youth who spent 6 months in the program.
Generalizability
This study was not generalizable to CSF Buxmont students who participated in the auxiliary programs but did not participate in the school program. It is not possible to generalize the outcomes of this study outside of the target population.
Black youth were more likely to receive a new court petition after completing the program. The effect of exposure to CSF Buxmont schools on the reduction of new court petitions was still significant after controlling for race.
Potential Limitations
Each of the evaluations lacked a randomized experimental design (no control group). McCold 2002 relied upon pre-post measures of outcomes, with no longitudinal data collected or analyzed. McCold 2005 and McCold and Chang 2008 included long-term follow-up data of Waves 1 and 2, but again did not include a control group for comparison. In addition, Wave 2 youths who received CSF community services following discharge from day treatment demonstrated an accelerated rate of recidivism through the end of the first year to nearly match that of the short-stay behaviorally-discharged youths.
Endorsements
Blueprints: Insufficient Evidence
Study 1
Evaluation Methodology
Design: This study evaluated the effectiveness of the restorative principles in encouraging positive behavioral change. Researchers evaluated all youth released from CSF Buxmont schools between June 1, 1999 and August 30, 2001 (Wave 1). The CSF Buxmont schools were evaluated using a protocol titled the Program Development and Evaluation System (ProDES). Researchers collected information on each youth's current offense, prior record, socio-demographic information, and family structure. ProDES also utilized information related to risk and needs assessments, and self-esteem and values assessments, all of which it evaluated at three points: program entry, program discharge, and a six-month follow-up. Follow-up data is collected by checking official court records, through the self-report of juveniles, and interviews with the juveniles' caregivers. All new admissions were interviewed within one month and assessed not sooner than a week nor later than a month following admission. New admissions were students entering SSF Buxmont schools for the first time and students returning after an absence of three months or more (excluding summer break). Students returning with less than three months of interruption were treated as a continuous stay with a period "out of program." The average length of exposure was 104 school days (20.9 weeks), with a minimum of none (2 youths) and a maximum of 531 days (106 weeks). For normal discharges, the average length of stay was 118 school days (23.7 weeks), compared to 77.2 school days (15.4 weeks) for behavioral discharges. Sixty-six percent of youth discharged from CSF were discharged for normal reasons. Other discharge reasons included repeated failure to respond to the program (16%), extended absences or runaways (12%), and new placement order due to a new arrest or violation of probation (7%). Those youth referred by probation were significantly more likely to receive a normal discharge (72% of 516) than were those referred by schools (58% of 315) or by children and youth services (60% or 88). Three hundred thirteen youth were discharged for behavioral reasons. Among those who received behavioral discharges, 32% of youth referred by probation were discharged for receiving a new arrest, compared to 12% of school and none of the children and youth referrals. School referred youth were more likely to be discharged for failure to attend (40%) than were those referred by probation (32%) or children and youth services (20%). Children and youth referrals were more likely to be discharged for failure to respond (80% of 35) than probation (36% of 147) or school referred youth (48% of 131). Overall, matched intake-exit interviews were collected among half (49.8%) of the 919 discharged youth. Compliance with the protocols for the 665 youth admitted after August 1999 was 94% for assessments, 84% for intake interviews, and 80% for exit interviews. Eighty-eight percent of all intake interviews were conducted within the 30-day window. Follow-up data is collected by checking official court records, through the self-report of juveniles, and interviews with the juveniles' caregivers.
The performance of CSF Buxmont schools was analyzed using three measures: program completion, youth attitudes, and offending following discharge. Program completion measured the number of youth that were discharged normally. As a restorative-based program, the ability of CSF to retain youth (thereby forcing youth to take an active role in their development) is an important measure of its success. The second measure analyzed the amount of change in youth attitudes as a result of program exposure. Participants were interviewed on a series of questions related to self-esteem and social values at program entry and exit. Results were compared to calculate attitudinal changes. Finally, any existing official court documents (i.e., arrests) were used to assess each youth's behavior in the six months after discharge.
Wave 2 (McCold 2005): This evaluation examined the effects of the CSF Buxmont day treatment program on a second Wave of 858 youths discharged during the September-August school years of 2001-2002 and 2002-2003. For comparison purposes, youths released during the previous Wave (McCold 2002) were included in the record check for reoffending data, allowing for computing recidivism rates for a 24-month period for youths in the first Wave.
Building upon the experience of the previous evaluation, the protocols for data collection were revised. Rather than measuring youths at program entry and exit, interviews and evaluations were conducted upon admission, at 3-month, 6-month and 12-month periods. Results regarding the effects of CSF Buxmont programs on youths' social attitudes, self-esteem, family bonding and school bonding were not reported. Instead, this evaluation reported on the factors affecting recidivism as measured by a petition in juvenile court for a new offense. In the previous Wave, data were collected only for youths participating in CSF Buxmont day treatment programs. Youths who only participated in the Intensive Program (IP) or Home and Community Supervision program (HCS) were not included in the first Wave but were included in the current (second) Wave. Thus, the sampling frame was enlarged to encompass all youths receiving services from CSF Buxmont. Protocols for collecting reoffending data were the same for the first and second Waves of data collection. In both Waves, juvenile and adult court records were searched manually, using name matches supplemented with date of birth, where available. Record searches were completed for all youths from Bucks, Montgomery, and Northampton counties, which constitutes 95% of the total. Youths released during the previous Wave were included in this record check, along with youths released during the second Wave. In addition to recording petitions occurring after a juvenile was released, all petition information was collected on all youths in both samples. This allowed for a calculation of the number of prior petitions and the age upon first petition, rather than relying upon self-reported data, as was done in the first Wave.
Wave 3 (McCold and Chang 2008): A total of 2,151 youth were discharged from CSF Buxmont programs during the three school years ending in August 2004, 2005, and 2006. Students were referred from schools (SC), children and youth services (C & Y) and juvenile probation (JP). Just over half (54%) of CSF Buxmont youth were referred by JP, 35% from SC, and 11% from C & Y. Most youth had only one referral source, but a total of 130 were referred by multiple sources. Nearly three quarters (74%) of the youth had some exposure to Day Treatment (DT), while the rest received only Home and Community (HCS) services or Intensive Program (IP) services. A total of 543 of these youth spent some time in one or more CSF Buxmont Residential Program (RP), 708 received HCS and 369 received IP services. One-fourth of the youth participated for 3 months or less in some CSF Buxmont service, half participated for 6 months or less and one quarter for 11 months or longer (mean = 8.1 months). Among those participating in DT, half did so for 4 months or less (men = 5.3 months); in RP, half spent 4 months or less (mean = 4.5 months). Among those receiving IP services, half participated for 6 months or less (mean = 6 months), and among those receiving HCS services, half participated for 3 months or less (mean = 3.4 months).
Factors related to school/day treatment completion rates included three interrelated risk factors: referral source, race and prior offending. Students referred by probation or schools (54% and 52%) had higher completion than those referred by children and youth services (43%). Black and Hispanic students completed at lower rates (43% and 41% than their white counterparts (56%). Those entering with no or one prior court petition completed at a higher rate (55% and 54%) than those with 2 to 3 priors (48%) or 4 or more priors (39%). Participation in one or more of the CSF Buxmont community programs was related to the proportion completing the school/day treatment to normal discharge, reducing the rate by 6% for residential care, but increasing the rates by 6% for IP and 9% for HCS. Participation in either CSF Buxmont community supervision program (IP or HCS) also increased program completion by 8%. Similar factors accounted for differences in normal completion rates for residential care, IP services and HCS as well.
In order to determine how these program effects might exacerbate or counterbalance the risk factors, a Cox multivariate survival analysis was used to determine the unique contribution of each of these factors. Prior petitions, being white and participating in either of the CSF Buxmont community supervision programs (IP or HCS) best account for program drop-outs. Once these were accounted for, the negative effect of residential care became non-significant. Thus, it is not the effects of participation in residential care, but rather the risk factors of the youth in that program that explains the lower completion rate.
During the spring of 2007, an extensive search of computerized juvenile and adult records was conducted in Bucks, Montgomery, Delaware, Northampton, Chester, Lehigh and Berks counties, covering 97.5% of the total. All new court petitions other than violations of probation orders were recorded, allowing for a complete delinquency history for each youth for the entire period prior to admission and at least six months after discharge. A series of multivariate techniques were used to analyze the data.
Sample: The total number of youth released in that time span was 919, including 140 from the final two weeks of the 1998-1999 school years, 334 from the 1999-2000 year, and 445 from the 2000-2001 year. Girls represented 28% of youth discharged from the CSF Buxmont Schools program between June 1, 1999 and August 30, 2001. Twenty-three percent of youth were less than 15 years-old, 21% were 15 years-old, 27% were 16 years-old, 22% were 17 years-old, 5% were 18 years-old, and data was missing for 2%. Most youth referred to CSF Buxmont schools were white (77%), followed by Black (11%) and Hispanic (7%). In addition to the school program, as previously mentioned, youth had three auxiliary programs which they could be involved with simultaneously. Not all youth who participated in these auxiliary programs were enrolled in a CSF Buxmont School, so these individuals were excluded from the analysis.
The Wave 2 sample was 68% female, and half were 16 or older when they entered the program. Most (71%) were white, with black youths constituting 14% of the sample, and Hispanic youths another 11%. Nearly half of the youths were from Bucks County (48%) and there were 26 fewer students in the more recent school year. Youths referred by schools were 43% of the total and were slightly less likely to be male, younger, less likely to be white and much more likely to be from Montgomery County than their counterparts from probation. Youths referred by juvenile probation were 47% of the total and were less likely to be female, older, more likely to be white and much more likely to come from Bucks County than their counterparts referred by school. The remaining 10% of the sample was referred by the state social services agency, Children and Youth (C&Y). A majority of these youths were girls (56%), much younger, more likely to be Hispanic (30%) and more evenly distributed across Bucks, Montgomery and Northampton counties than either school or court-referred youths.
The Wave 3 sample was 68% male, 74% white, 16% black, 7% Hispanic, and 3% other. Seventy-three percent of the sample was between 15 and 17 years old upon admission, and 48% of were referred out of Bucks County.
Measures: ProDES utilizes the 38-item Jessness Values Scale to measure changes in youths' attitudes toward social values. It also includes a 10 item self-esteem scale to measure changes in a youth's self-image. The scale ranges from 1 for the lowest to 10 for the highest.
The performance of CSF Buxmont schools was evaluated using three distinct measures: program completion, youth attitudes, and offending following discharge. Restorative practices demand that youth take an active role in maintaining the behavior and safety of the community, so it was expected that CSF Buxmont would retain youth at rates higher than other comparable programs (program completion). Changes in youth attitudes were measured by comparing each youth's response to a series of interview questions designed to measure social values and self-esteem administered shortly after entering the program to those concurrent with their discharge. Offending following discharge was measured by reviewing juvenile and adult court records and noting any petitions for arrests occurring during the six months following discharge from CSF Buxmont schools. Arrests occurring while attending and resulting in discharge were not included in this measurement.
Analysis: Results of data collected upon admission to the program were compared to data collected at the six-month follow-up for analysis.Outcomes
Program Completion:
Youth referred by probation and those charged with drug offenses (no matter the referral source) were more likely to complete the program than other youth. Only 41% black females received a normal discharge, compared to above 60% for all other race/gender groups. Youth who were in CSF residential care in addition to the CSF Buxmont Schools were more likely than others to remain in the program longer than average. None of the demographic or delinquency variables were significantly related to the time until behavioral discharge.
Youth Attitudes:
Social Values: A total of 656 intake interviews were conducted within the first six weeks of attendance at a CSF Buxmont school, of which 414 (63%) had matching exit interviews. Social values on program entry had a mean of 5.34 (with a median of 5). A small percentage of youth became less positive throughout their involvement with the program (9%), while most youth remained fairly constant (57%), and a third developed more positive social values (34%). A majority of youth showed some improvement between measures. The net improvement was larger for those normally discharged than those behaviorally discharged. Youths who were discharged for behavior had lower intake social value scores (mean = 4.97) than those who received normal discharges (mean = 5.44). For youth who were normally discharged, there was an average significant 10.6% increase in positive social values. For youth who were behaviorally discharged, there was no significant average change in positive social values. At intake, 90% of youth agreed with the statement, "When I get into trouble, its my own fault," compared with 100% at exit. All youth also became less likely to agree with the statement, "I am blamed at home for things that are not my fault" (from 56% to 48%). Youth discharged for normal reasons were also significantly less likely to agree with the statement, "I do not get a fair chance" (26% to 19%), unlike youth discharged for behavioral reasons (36.9% to 38.1%). All youth were more likely to agree with the statement, "Police try to help" (47% to 100%). Finally, normal discharges became less likely to agree that "People in authority are bossy" (59% to 53%), while no similar significant changes were found for behavioral discharges (63% to 66%).
Self-esteem: The 10 item self-esteem scale discovered highly skewed levels of self esteem (mean = 7.88, median = 9, mode = 11). The self-esteem score on entry proved to be a good estimator of self-esteem score on exit. A small percentage of youth had lower levels of self-esteem at exit (10%), most remained stable (66%), and almost a quarter of youth had substantial increases in self-esteem (24%). Youth with normal discharges were more likely to experience increases in self-esteem compared to behavioral discharges (27% vs. 14%). The average amount of self-esteem increase was 8.8% among normal discharges, compared to essentially no change in behavioral discharges. Finally, normal discharges experienced significant increases on eight of ten self-esteem questions (compared to zero for behavioral discharges).
There was a statistically significant relationship for normal discharges between program exposure and change in attitudes -- the longer normally discharged youth were exposed to CSF Buxmont schools, the more positive their values and self-esteem became. Social value scores increased .0183 for every week of involvement with the program. Self-esteem scores increased an average of .0217 for every week of participation. These improvements in social values and self-esteem were unrelated to referral source, gender, age, race, risk, or to participation in an auxiliary program.
Offending Following Discharge:
Court records were available for 96% of the 919 youth discharged from CSF Buxmont schools. About 10% had a new court petition and 5.6% had violated their probation during the 6 months following discharge. Individuals discharged for behavioral reasons were almost twice as likely as those with normal discharges to reoffend (15.1% vs. 7.9%). School referred youth were more likely to have a new court petition (11.6% of 303) than probation (10.1% of 496) or those referred by children and youth services (8% of 87). Youth with a prior arrest, black youth, and youth 16 years old or younger upon entry at CSF Buxmont schools were more likely to receive a new court petition (14%, 18% and 12%, respectively). The probability of reoffense was related to the length of participation in CSF Buxmont schools. For the 277 youth who participated less than three months, the reoffense rate was 16.2%, compared to 7.7% (n = 609) for those who remained longer than three months. Youth who received a normal discharge were less likely to violate their probation and less likely to receive a new court petition. Those who attended three months or more of CSF Buxmont schools and received normal discharges, representing 52% of the total, had the lowest rate of new court petitions (6.1%), while behavioral discharges with less than three months of participation had the highest rate (17.6%).
Researchers estimated both a linear and nonlinear correlation between length of exposure to CSF Buxmont schools and new court petition rates. The nonlinear approximation was a more accurate estimate. For youth attending CSF Buxmont, the clearest period of reduction in reoffense rates followed immediately after the 3 month attendance threshold. At five months, the effect leveled off. A risk variable was created to account for any prior arrest history and age at time of admission to CSF Buxmont schools. The variable had three categories: 1) low risk [youth 16 years or older and no prior arrests]; 2) medium risk [youth 16 years or older with prior arrest]; 3) high risk [youth younger than 16 with prior arrest]. The risk variable was a strong predictor of new court petitions, with 8% of 641 low risk youth, 13% of 109 medium risk youth, and 19% of 136 high risk youth reoffending within six months. The risk variable was also strongly predictive of probation violations for low, medium, and high risk individuals (20%, 23%, and 30%, respectively).
The effect of exposure to CSF Buxmont schools on the reduction of new court petitions was still significant after controlling for race and risk.
Wave 1 (McCold 2005): The new court record checks on Wave 1 youths revealed many more new court petitions than were found during the previous effort, although the general pattern was replicated. The recidivism rate was reduced from 24% to 15% for behavior discharges for those completing three months of day treatment, a 37% reduction. In addition, youths discharged normally reduced their reoffending from 19% to 9.5%, a 50% reduction for those participating more than 3 months.
The effect from three months of participation was still evident by 24 months from discharge, although substantially reduced. Participation of 3 months or more for behavior-discharged youths was associated with a 20% reduction in new court petitions and by 13% for those discharged normally. The trends in reoffending maintained their ranking at the 6-month period throughout the 24-months, with youths discharged for their behavior with less than three months participation having the highest rate (48%) and those discharged normally with more than three months the lowest (32%). Youths who received CSF community services following discharge from day treatment (n = 180) received an average of five months care, after which their recidivism rate accelerated through the end of the first year to nearly match that of the short-stay behaviorally-discharged youths.
Wave 2: The effect of participating in the CSF Buxmont day treatment program for more than three months displayed the same pattern of new court petitions at 6 months as did Wave 1. The rate of recidivism for youths discharged for their behavior declined after three months of participation by 8%, compared to a 44% reduction for youths normally discharged.
A number of multivariate analyses on the Wave 2 data revealed that the factors most closely related to the risk of receiving a new court petition within 6 months of release were gender and age on first petition. The younger the youth at their first court petition, the greater the rate of recidivism. Youths with no prior petitions have the lowest rate of recidivism. Moreover, the rate of recidivism is higher for boys than for girls, regardless of the age at first petition.
These results were highly correlated with the number of prior arrests, number of petitions, age at first out-of-home placement and risk scales computed from intake data. These other variables became insignificantly related to recidivism once gender and age at first petition were entered. Since these data were available on all youths with court checks, these two measures were used to create an expected rate of recidivism. The linear slopes were computed separately for boys and girls, and the expected probability for receiving a new court petition was calculated from these equations. Youths with no prior court petition were assigned an expected rate of 0%. The reduction in new court petitions from three months participation changed little for behavior at 13% and was reduced to 30% for normal discharges when youths petitioned for probation violation were removed from the sample.
Multivariate analysis found that the number of days present was significantly associated with lower recidivism, even after controlling the effects related to prior record (number of petitions, number of prior arrests, age on admission), gender and reason for program discharge. Finally, although the overall level of recidivism was a bit higher in the Wave 2 sample, the expected nonlinear effect of program participation was evident.
Wave 3 (McCold and Chang 2008): The Cox regression survival analysis on days to first court petition in juvenile court or adult court filing revealed five factors significantly related to the time until first court petition. Youth with a higher number of prior petitions were more likely to recidivate; youth who were older, were female, and completed CSF Buxmont school/day treatment to normal discharge were associated with surviving longer without a new petition. Independent of these risk factors, greater participation in CSF Buxmont school/day treatment was significantly associated with less recidivism.
The mean number of court petitions per person during the three months prior to admission were compared to the mean number of petitions occurring during the three months following discharge, as were the periods of 6 and 12 months prior to admission compared to the same periods following discharge. Dividing these mean incidence rates by the number of months in the observation period produced a standardized monthly average rate of offending per client and allowed for the comparison of changes in different incidence rates. In general, the longer the time period used in the analysis (3, 6, or 12 months), the lower the incidence and the less the reduction in the rates, yet all three time periods measured demonstrated statistically significant reductions. For the total population, the changes were -62% (n = 1,581) for 3 months, -60% (n = 1,581) for 6 months, and -53% (n = 1,254) for 12 months. In summary, for all pre-post time windows, the average number of petitions per person was reduced by more than half.
Using the middle-range recidivism measure (6-month pre-post time periods) it was possible to compare the magnitude of the individual factor effects. The changes in rates of recidivism were more dramatic for those completing the program (-65%) than for those with an early discharge (-52%), although both reductions were statistically significant. Students participating for more than 6 months had greater reductions in incidence rates (-72%) than those with less than 6 months (-52%), again with both reductions reaching statistical significance. Differences in reductions of recidivism were much more dramatic for those with less than 4 months of participation (-42%) than for those participating for 4 to 8 months (-69%) and 9 or more months (-75%). Overall, the effective length of participation for producing the largest declines in offending rates occurred at approximately 6 months. When examined in terms of prevalence rates for those participating for different lengths of time (i.e., receiving different dosages), the incident rate fluctuated widely but displayed a general linear decline of about 1.3% reduction per additional month of participation. These data better fit a second-order polynomial trend line, with a tipping point of effective dosage occurring after about 6 months of participation.